Gene Wiki Jamboree 1 - post mortem
Last week I had the honor of leading a Gene Wiki Jamboree at the annual meeting of the FaceBase Consortium (an association of researchers focused on understanding the genetics craniofacial development). The FaceBase group is creating a centralized resource for sharing their data and their knowledge with the hope of generally cross-fertilizing ideas and specifically enabling analyses that span the domains and datatypes of the very diverse members in the group. As part of this effort they want to compile and share their knowledge about genes that are relevant to craniofacial development. Rather than, or perhaps in addition to, the creation of their own wiki they are hoping to do this in the context of the Gene Wiki - hence my appearance at their meeting.
In general, the goal of a 'jamboree' in the context of biology is to bring a group of people together to rapidly assemble their knowledge on some specific subject. To my knowledge, the first usage of the term in that fashion was the Drosophila Genome Annotation Jamboree at Celera in 1999 (please let me know if there was an earlier use). In that case, more than 40 scientists gathered together for 2 weeks to define the boundaries of the fly genes and to classify their function. Not being a company like Celera nor having a whole, brand new genome to work on, the size of our group and our time allotment was much smaller. In total we only had about 8 people and 90 minutes...
Given those constraints, this jamboree was really more of a tutorial. It took about 45 minutes to get everyone in the room set up with an account and through their first 'edit this page' experience. So in the end, not a lot of content was generated. But, everyone did succeed in making an edit, seemed happy with their experience, and were clearly much more likely to edit something in the future than they were before the jamboree. So.. I think it was a success given the situation.
A couple notes on the process:
- We set up a friendfeed group so that people could ask questions remotely and could track what others were doing (we added RSS feeds for the contributors edits). This was not used at all. None of the participants was a previous friendfeed user and they were also completely new to the Wikipedia experience. It seemed that the attention load of learning the Wiki way was more than enough to occupy them. Also, everyone was on laptops which limited the screen space for a flow-interface like friendfeed. I still like the idea of the ff-group as a live view on the progress and thoughts of the community, but for an in-person jamboree we will have to think of a different approach to achieve that kind of collective awareness. Perhaps a separate projector with the flow view..
- Principle Investigators with their own very busy agendas really aren't the best participants in a jamboree. To be more effective, we need people with more time to focus on the task (graduate students please..)
- We need more time! Doing a good job editing the text of a scientific review article isn't the easiest thing to do, more time would really help. This is especially the case when working in an editing environment where, if you are adding references, the text you are typing starts looking like this:
VEGFR-2 appears to mediate almost all of the known cellular responses to VEGF {{cite journal | author = Holmes K, Roberts OL, Thomas AM, Cross MJ. | title = Vascular endothelial growth factor receptor-2: structure, function, intracellular signalling and therapeutic inhibition. | journal = Cell Signal. | volume = 19 | issue = 10 | pages = 2003–2012 | year = 2007 | month = Oct | pmid = 17658244}}.
Yuck...
- Watch out for edit conflicts. When some one is editing their very first page, the last thing that you want to happen is for some one else to be editing it at the same time. While it could be construed as a useful lesson, its really more than is needed for edit #1. This is something that anyone leading a tutorial like this should consciously avoid since its easy to accidentally create situations where it is likely - for example, by going to a sandbox page or other and having everyone edit it at the same time or even just posting a list of pages to edit (most people will start on the top).
- Finally, it is vital to have some kind of central coordinating page where links to help resources and to-do lists can be assembled. I probably didn't give this enough thought on this run, but will be sure to make this a priority in my preparations if I get the chance to lead another Jamboree.
setup Nominatim for postgis 8.4 on karmic
Why we need wikis
Working on a Wiki
Obama Spooked By WikiLeaks
Wiki - Quick - Thing #16
SEIU Thuggery - A Post From The Draft Doldrums
BLUEDOT、何百万というウィキペディアの記事をインターネット不要で楽しめる「WikiReader ウィキリーダー」を発売ウィキリーダー 正面ウィキリーダー 側面使用イメージ使用イメージ
Wiki Rummage #2: Stress Management
Probabilistic Partioning of the Gene Ontology - anyone?
Strolling through Google and Wiki
i9606: Gene Wiki Jamboree 1 - post mortem
Jun 7, 2010 Gene Wiki Jamboree 1 - post mortem. Last week I had the honor of leading a Gene Wiki Jamboree at the annual meeting of the FaceBase
Benjamin Good - FriendFeed
Continuous chinese spam, 414 error for a comment I posted that was too long. .... Gene Wiki Jamboree 1 - post mortem - http://i9606.blogspot.com/2010.
Ian Mulvany - FriendFeed
Gene Wiki Jamboree 1 - post mortem - http://i9606.blogspot.com/2010... June 28 from Google Reader - Comment - Like - Share. Behavioral Profiling at Airports
Beta Science: Pseudomonas and Langille in the media
Jan 27, 2009 Gene Wiki Jamboree 1 - post mortem. 4 days ago. Public Rambling · Genetic interactions in powers of ten. 2 weeks ago
Help Me With a List of Great Monster Music [Archive] - Straight
55 posts - 40 authors - Last post: Feb 16, 2008"Haunted House" by Jumpin' Gene Simmons Zombie Jamboree! http://www.youtube.
StateMaster - Encyclopedia: Kukla, Fran and Ollie
The puppet cast included Kukla, the earnest leader of the troupe (who looked like a clown American television game show, most often hosted by Gene Rayburn. Fran said she thought a post-mortem might be funny---everybody could be very The Wikipedia article included on this page is licensed under the GFDL.
Woman Hello
Jun 30, 2010 ag2 Carrie Underwood performing at Jamboree in the Hills in Ohio on July 19-22 Kabale Revises Post-Mortem Fees
Links 20/5/2010: Robin Hood Powered By Linux | Techrights
May 20, 2010 Porting Osmos to Linux: A Post-Mortem (part 2/3) Part 1 lay the foundations for the article and where we're coming from. ..... help drive down some costs – a happy coincidence for the Camelegg jamboree? ..... Site Wiki: You can improve this site by helping the extension of the site's content
CiteULike: ptrobajo's gene [97 articles]
along with 7 people and 1 group marti djkt roys provero gotgenes lp2 genetic mouse models of Huntington's disease (HD) and postmortem human HD caudate.
pocket - start [NPL Wiki]
gendarme gendarmerie gender gene genealogy genera general generalissimo .... jailbreak jailer jalap jalopy jalousie jam jamb jamboree jangle janitor jape ..... postman postmark postmaster postmistress postmortem postnasal postnatal